Advanced Dungeons & Dragons: Heroes of the Lance
System: NES Publisher: FCI Developer: U.S. Gold
Genre: Adventure Type: Sidescrolling Circa: 1991
...

Of all the hundreds of games that were released for the NES, there was none other quite like the oddity that is Heroes of the Lance. It is largely regarded as one of the worst games of all time, making several notable "worst lists", including Electronic Gaming Monthly's and Nintendo Power's. Many gamers who have played Heroes find it too difficult and frustrating to complete, which is a stark contrast to Nintendo Power's claim that it could be beaten in less than five minutes. Having finished it several times myself, I can safely say that both scenarios are an exaggeration, though the latter only because the characters move so damn slowly.

Based on a PC game of the same name (which I've never played), you take on the role of eight heroes from the DragonLance books (which I've never read), as they attempt to recover the Disks of Mishakal from the ruined city of Xak Tsaroth. What follows next is one of the biggest "how the hell could they have let it hit the store shelves like this?" gaming experiences you are ever likely to have.

...

While any number of the game's drawbacks could easily stand out first, the play control and combat system will be amongst them. Characters move very slowly, starting at a walking pace and eventually gaining speed into a brisk trot the longer you hold down the direction pad. As an enemy approaches you can (and probably must) engage it in combat. Combat amounts to standing in one spot while repeatedly swinging your weapon, since you cannot attack while moving. You will inevitably take damage from your foe since there is no blocking or dodging. (A shield system like what Zelda 2: The Adventure of Link or Sword Master used would've been a step in the right direction.)

As you would expect from a Dungeons & Dragons game, there are also attack spells and healing spells that can be utilized if the correct characters are in the front row of the party. The spells are cast from a wand that has a limited charge, but the game is so short and the mp supply so abundant, I use the spells quite liberally and never come close to running out. If you hit upon the correct spell, (and since most are useless, you probably will), you'll find a way to pass by most enemies with impunity, which is my personal secret for beating this game.

...

The world of Xak Tsaroth is a maze that is not really all that confounding, especially if you map it or take notes. What Xak Tsaroth is, however, is one of the most dreary and bleak videogame settings I've ever seen. The backgrounds are made up entirely of four colors: black, grey, a lighter grey, and a chartreuse green. (Someone probably should have informed the graphics designer that he wasn't working for a CGA system.) It's ugly, dismal, and though occasionally it manages an interesting visual in the earlier areas (like an inexplicable giant pot on a pulley and a weird statue room), the final area consists of a bunch of sewer tunnels that all look alike and are devoid of any pits or puzzles.

I'm suspicious the maze was originally planned to be larger than it is because the farther you go, the more you'll find East/West doors and North/South doors that both lead to the same room. Many items, including treasures, weapons, shields, and potions, are scattered around, but there is hardly need to collect any of them.

...

The main problem with Heroes of the Lance is that it's very obviosly unpolished and unfinished. You have eight heroes with varying stats, but very little of this matters, since the game is not designed to take full advantage of their unique traits. I usually rely on just three of the characters to get by, one to fight, one to heal, one to use attack spells and cross the pits. Oh, yes, the pits - the source of much dismay for gamers who have trekked far enough through Xak Tsaroth to come to them. Because most of the characters have extremely poor jumping abilities, it is menacingly difficult to jump the pits, unless you know a little secret that makes them a breeze. (No, I won't give it away here.)

Aside from some nice character portraits shown at the game's start, the graphics in Heroes are a mess, but the audio is more successful. Some of the music is actually rather good. The second area theme is my favorite song in the game with its foreboding tone, and the final area music is nice, too. The ending song is a decent reward for actually finishing this monstrosity. The sound effects are not spectacular, but serviceable (enemies have footsteps, spells and warps have good 8-bit quality). The voiceovers used for when you or an enemy takes damage are unfortunately cheesy. Enemies all have the same grunt when attacked, whether you're fighting a human barbarian or a spider. Even cheesier, the female in your party (Goldmoon) has the same voice clip as all the men!

...

Despite all the "what-the-fuckery" you will trudge through on your way to the final boss, nothing can prepare you for it, or rather, the ridiculous way in which it's fallen. Although the manual explicitly tells you what to do, it's almost hard to believe that's all there really is to it, until you reach that Moment of Truth. Of course, if you don't have the manual, it might be awhile before you figure out the whopping ONE step needed to complete your mission. (It's acually possible to screw yourself out of being able to do that during the course of the game if you aren't careful.)

The underwhelming quality of Heroes's design is especially odd when considering how much effort went into crafting the manual. Written by someone who apparently did their homework on the DragonLance books, it offers long, detailed explanations of who each character is and why they're on this quest. (The game itself contains neither.) Perhaps the manual's writers were under the delusion that this was going to be a great epic game, or maybe they were compensating for its shortcomings.

...

I didn't come away from Heroes of the Lance hating it as much as the rest of the world does. It is so odd, so unusual, and has such a unique atmosphere, that it's almost worth playing just to see how weird it is. There isn't anything else quite like it, not even the Japan-only sequel, Dragons of Flame, that's advertised in the ending. Which leaves me wondering... why be so quick to foist a sequel on us when the current game was so incomplete?

OVERALL SCORE: 1.5/5

DISCUSS THIS REVIEW IN THE GAME REVIEW FORUM

BACK TO NES REVIEWS

BACK TO MAIN PAGE

AddThis Social Bookmark Button Dreamhost